Parshat Mishpatim
Thought, Speech and Action
Daniel R. Weiss
Middle School Judaic Studies Principal/K-8 Judaic Program Coordinator
dweiss@grossschechter.org
In last week’s Parsha, Yitro, we read that God gave the Ten Commandments to the Jewish people. Much has been written about the Ten Commandments: their order, significance and how they were divided onto the two tablets.
Before we go any further, here’s the complete list of Ten Commandments.
- Believe in God
- Don’t pray to idols
- Don’t use God’s name in vain
- Observe Shabbat
- Honor your parents
- Don’t murder
- Don’t commit adultery
- Don’t steal
- Don’t bear false witness
- Don’t covet
According to Rabbi Shimshon Raphael Hirsch the first five commandments deal with the relationship between people and God (bein adam laMakom). The second five deal with commandments that are bein adam l’adam (person to person relationships). This theory seems problematic since the fifth commandment (honoring your parents) appears to be a person-to-person issue. If we consider, however, that our parents were God’s partners in our creation, we can better understand that God is part of the parental relationship.
Another theory regarding the division of the commandments is that one tablet had the first commandment and the second had the last nine. This would imply that if you do not believe in the first commandment, you don’t need to go any further.
Rabbi Hirsch suggests another interesting perspective. He suggests that one must look at them side by side. The following illustration will help.
We begin with thought: belief in God, not believing in idols. We then move to speech: not using God’s name in vain. Finally to action: keeping Shabbat, honoring our parents. When it comes to our relationship with God, we move from “think” to “speech” to “act.” In other words, we think before we act.
When it comes to our relationship with people, we act (don’t murder, don’t commit adultery, don’t steal) before we speak (don’t bear false witness), and certainly before we think things entirely through (don’t covet).
In looking at this approach, we can see the interplay and cyclical nature of the commandments: we internalize main ideas before we speak; we speak before we act; we return to our speech and finally internalize our speech and actions.
Here are ways this interplay works out:
- If we believe in God and trust that He will provide for us, we don’t need to covet what our neighbor has (one and ten).
- Slandering and misrepresenting our neighbor is similar to worshipping idols, in that we are misrepresenting our belief in man and God (two and nine).
- When we use God’s name in vain, we are stealing from the sanctity of His name (three and eight).
- If we do not realize that Shabbat is a symbol of our relationship with God and with creation, much like adultery, we are cheating on our partner (four and seven).
- Finally, the commandment of honoring our parents is given the reward (the only one of the ten with a reward) that our days will be lengthened. Dishonoring them is in effect limiting our days, which could be tantamount to murder (five and six).
This interplay among the Commandments can apply to other laws in the Torah. In Mishpatim we are taught, “One who strikes his father or his mother shall surely be put to death.” According to Rashi, the cause of this death would be strangulation – making our words unintelligible. We carry a heavy mantle both in our speech and through our action. We are the legacy of our parents. By showing them dishonor we are destroying their legacy.
The mitzvah of shooing away the mother bird before one takes her eggs is also given the reward of the lengthening of days. It seems odd that such an easy mitzvah of shooing away a bird and such a difficult mitzvah of honoring our parents would carry the same reward. One answer to this dilemma is that it teaches us that each mitzvah is equally important, from the easiest to the hardest, whether we understand their meaning or not.
When looking at the various laws in the Torah some appear to make sense based on our reason, while others seem to be “beyond” reason. In reality, all of the mitzvot are important and linked. As a complete system, they require us to weigh our thoughts, speech and actions, and they all assume a belief in God and the spark of the divine that exists in every human being.







Loading...